From David Irving via Carlo Mattogno to Thomas Olson
Source:
https://codoh.com/library/document/rigging-holocaust-testimony/
by Germar Rudolf
October 11, 2026
Last
updated on October 14, 2026
In
late June of 1996, I moved to England’s beautiful sunshine coast, taking up
residence with my family in Pevensey Bay, right in the middle of 1066 country.
That move had been suggested by a number of friends, among them British
historian David Irving, who suggested that I finish my PhD studies in the UK.
Several weeks later, Irving asked me whether I would join him in his van
delivering his latest book Nuremberg: The Last Battle. He had to drop
off a pallet of it at Gardners, which had their main warehouse in Eastbourne, a
few miles west of where I lived, and then deliver another couple of pallets
headed for the U.S. at a London freight forwarder.
It
honestly baffled me why he would ask me to accompany him, but since I had
nothing better to do at that time, I agreed. During the ride from Eastbourne to
London, Irving revealed the reason why he wanted me to join him. He told me that
he was preparing a libel lawsuit against Deborah Lipstadt and her British
publishing company Penguin book. Irving didn’t like the way Lipstadt had
maligned him in her 1993 book Denying the Holocaust. He told me that
most media outlets he had threatened with lawsuits in the past had agreed on
settling out of court, so he hoped the same here. In case Lipstadt and Penguin
wouldn’t settle, he planned on presenting evidence demonstrating how writings
such as those by Lipstadt lead to censorship, stigmatization, ostracism,
persecution and even prosecution of scholars voicing responsible but dissident
views on the Holocaust. He wanted me to play a crucial role in this as a young
fledgling scholar testifying, and supporting with documents, how my livelihood
had been turned upside down as a result of my forensic research into Auschwitz,
resulting in a landslide of persecution. I have described that history in my
book Hunting Germar Rudolf.
Irving moreover assured me that my research results would not be part of my
possible testimony, as he wanted to keep the Holocaust itself outside the
courtroom. He wanted to focus only on the devastation which writings such as
Lipstadt’s have on people. I assured Irving that I would be happy to assist.
History
took a completely different turn, though. Lipstadt and Penguin Books decided to
put the Holocaust itself centerstage during that trial. Irving was utterly
unprepared for this. First of all, because he had not expected to have to
address this topic at all in court. But more importantly, because he was not an
expert on that topic. In fact, he had never written a single article about it,
let alone a book, and had done no research in that field either. In fact, when I
visited him in late spring of 1996 in his London abode, he showed me a copy of
my book Grundlagen zur Zeitgschichte (English:
Dissecting the Holocaust, now in its
4th edition) standing in one of his bookshelves. However, as he was quick to
point out, he prided himself on not having read it. “I never read other people’s
books. I only consult primary sources,” he told me. But that, he hadn’t done
either when it comes to the Holocaust.
As was
to be expected, the resulting trial was a disaster for him, as he didn’t know
what he was doing. He rejected offers by us revisionists to join him in the
courtroom in order to organize his defense. He merely wanted me to write an
expert report critically analyzing and “expert report” submitted by Jewish-Dutch
historian of architecture Robeert Jan van Pelt on Auschwitz.1]
When all this was unfolding in the fall of 1999, the British media were starting
a witch hunt against me. Regional TV stations in the south even showed portraits
of mine during news reports, claiming that I was part of a “new breed of
dangerous Nazis.” Germany was asking for my extradition to throw me into prison
for my forensic research. To top it off, in early 2000, Her Majesty’s government
answered an inquiry by a Labour member of parliament, saying that “the police
have also been informed” of me being in the country. That all threw a few monkey
wrenches in my ability to prepare the promised expert report for Irving,
especially because I decided in November of 1999 that the ground in the UK was
getting too hot for me. I left the country in late November 1999 and flew to the
U.S., with the plan to never return to Europe unless they come to their senses
and stop the witch hunts. I’m waiting for this to this day…
In the
end, Irving couldn’t make use of my quickly cobbled-together expert report2]
for several reasons. As a consequence, Dr. van Pelt’s narrative ultimately
prevailed. Ever since, mainstream media as well as the Holocaust orthodoxy have
been crowing that the “evil deniers” have been thoroughly defeated and refuted
during that cataclysmic London libel trial. The problem with this claim is that
revisionist arguments and the plethora of evidence backing them up have never
been presented during that trial. Irving’s ignorance in this field may have been
exposed, but that’s as far as it goes.
In 2002,
van Pelt’s expert report appeared in a revised and expanded edition as a book.3]
Both in his 1999 expert report and in his book, van Pelt made ample use of the
term “convergence of evidence.” This concept means that different items of
evidence of various types, while not conclusive by themselves, still prove a
claim beyond reasonable doubt, because they all point to, hence converge in, one
and the same conclusion. That term was introduced into this discussion already
in 1994 by California-based science historian Michael Shermer, who, in an
article published in his periodical Skeptic Magazine, tried to refute
revisionist claims about the Holocaust.4] Shermer later
expanded on that article by writing an entire book about it,5]
although he got a Jewish commissar assigned to his side to make sure Shermer
doesn’t get off the orthodox track: Alex Grobman, the Jewish founding
editor-in-chief of the Simon Wiesenthal Center Annual. That makes you
ponder, “why would that have been necessary?” Well, after his initial 1994
Skeptic article, Shermer had accepted an invitation by the California-based
Institute for Historical Review, back then the world’s leading revisionist
institution. During the resulting panel discussion on July 22, 1995, Shermer
showed professional courtesy to the revisionist scholars and made several
concessions toward their position.6] Five years later,
the revisionist position had been buttressed by the discovery of many new
documents heretofore hidden in Moscow archives. Hence, Jewish pressure groups
must have been nervous about Shermer making even more concessions. With
Commissar Grobman on his side, however, Shermer backpaddled completely in his
2000 book.
Enter
Italian Holocaust historian Carlo Mattogno into the fray. That’s like putting
the revisionist fox in the orthodox henhouse. He put pen to paper and utterly,
devastatingly shredded both Shermer’s7] and van Pelt’s8]
delusions about Holocaust evidence presumably converging into their “truth.”
Mattogno demonstrated on the one hand that both van Pelt and Shermer
misrepresented and/or misinterpreted documents, forcing them to converge into a
preordained point, although their actual contents as well as historical and
documental context proves the exact opposite. On the other hand, Mattogno shows
that, yes, there is a convergence of anecdotal evidence, meaning of witness
accounts telling similar stories. However, these tales do not converge into a
truth, but demonstrably into falsehoods, clearly showing that these witnesses
must have been groomed in one way or another to tell the same lies.
Mattogno’s – and in extension the revisionists’ – week point is that he does not
provide any evidence for such grooming. In the books on other so-called
extermination camps he co-authored with others, Mattogno provides more cases of
witness testimonies converging into lies. The most glaring of them is the case
of the Sobibór Camp, where early witness statements converge on an absurd tale
that was subsequently ditched by the orthodoxy and replaced by a completely
different narrative.9] More to the point, early witness
claims about the three “Aktion Reinhardt” camps – Bełżec, Sobibór, Treblinka –
are surprisingly divergent either with regard to each other or to what the
orthodoxy’s claims to be true. I have laid this out succinctly in the respective
chapters of my book Nazi Gas Chambers: The Roots
of the Story.10] Again, we have several
circumstantially smoking guns, but no direct proof of anyone rigging the
anecdotal record.
That has
now changed. In a paper published in this issue of Inconvenient History
titled “Oskar Strawczynski and the Cross-Pollination of Holocaust Memory,”11]
U.S. researcher Thomas Olson takes a deep look into the background of survivor
testimony on the Treblinka Camp, which is claimed to have been the deadliest
among the so-called pure extermination camps with some 800,000 victims. Olson
reveals how survivors of the Treblinka Camp created an association for
themselves, which cooperated closely with the Central Jewish Historical
Commission. That commission spearheaded Jewish efforts to document what
presumably happened during the war, and to create “evidence” for criminal
investigations. As such, they all cooperated closely with Poland’s Main
Commission for the Investigation of Nazi Crimes in Poland, whose Investigative
Judge Zdzisław Łukaszkiewicz ultimately wrote the Treblinka narrative as it is
told to this day.
More to
the point, Olson documents that these Treblinka survivors met regularly with the
main purpose of recording their testimonies. However, this was not done by
having every witness submit their own recollections independently. Instead, as
documents about the applied methods state explicitly, witnesses were encouraged
to meet, to recount what they “knew” to others, and to read written accounts to
them in order to “jog” their memory. Participants could provide “additional
information, corrections” to what a witness knew off hand. The resulting written
testimonies were often the work of several authors, recognizable by some of
these accounts being written by several distinct handwritings.
With
regard to witness testimony, the argument of “converging evidence” makes sense
only if the witness accounts are independent from each other, all pointing in
the same direction. If they have been polluted by outside information,
especially by what other witnesses claim to know – a process Irving once called
“cross-pollination” – then these accounts are no longer independent, and cannot
be used to argue that they reinforce each other’s reliability or credibility. In
fact, the intentional and systematic cross-pollination of witness testimony
committed by those Jewish survivor organizations in Poland completely pulls the
rug out from underneath the “convergence” approach. If anything, it proves the
opposite.
I am
looking forward to more deep-diving archival studies by Thomas Olson. We are
proud to have him on our team of fiercely independent historical researchers.
Check
here for all of Olson’s papers published so far.
Endnotes
1.
The Pelt Report, 1999; in:
www.hdot.org/vanpelt_toc.
2.
A slightly revised version is posted online at
www.vho.org//GB/c/GR/RudolfOnVanPelt.html.
3.
The Case for Auschwitz. Evidence from the Irving Trial. Indiana
University Press, Bloomington/Indianapolis, 2002.
4.
Michael Shermer, “Proving the Holocaust: The Refutation of Revisionism & the
Restoration of History,” Skeptic Magazine, Vol. 2, No. 4 (June 1994),
pp. 32-57, especially his chapter on “A Convergence of Evidence: The Key to
Historical Proof,” online at
https://www.nizkor.org/a-convergence-of-evidence/.
5.
Michael Shermer, Alex Grobman, Denying History. Who Says the Holocaust Never
Happened and Why Do They Say It?, University of California, Berkeley, Los
Angeles, London 2000/2002/2009.
6.
Mark Weber, “Debating the Undebatable: The Weber-Shermer Clash,” The Journal
of Historical Review, Vol. 16, No. 1, 1996, pp. 23-34;
https://codoh.com/library/document/debating-the-undebatable-the-weber-shermer-clash/;
this include an almost 2-hour-long video recording of the debate.
7.
C. Mattogno, “‘Denying Historyֹ? – Denying Evidence!” The Revisionist,
Vol. 3, No. 1, 2005, pp. 9-44;
https://codoh.com/library/document/denying-history-denying-evidence/;
currently as a stand-alone book: idem, Bungled: “Denying History.” How
Michael Shermer and Alex Grobman Botched Their Attempt to Refute Those Who Say
the Holocaust Never Happened, 2nd ed., Castle Hill Publishers, Uckfield, 2017;
https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/bungled-denying-history/.
8.
C. Mattogno, The Real Case for Auschwitz: Robert van Pelt’s Evidence from
the Irving Trial Critically Reviewed, 3rd ed., Castle Hill Publishers,
Uckfield, 2019;
https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/the-real-case-for-auschwitz/.
9.
Carlo Mattogno, Thomas Kues, Jürgen Graf, Sobibór: Holocaust Propaganda and
Reality, 2nd ed., Castle Hill Publishers, Uckfield, 2020;
https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/sobibor/.
10.
3rd ed., Armreg Ltd, London, 2026;
https://holocausthandbooks.com/book/nazi-gas-chambers/.
11.
Inconvenient History, Vol. 18, No. 4, 2026;
https://codoh.com/library/document/oskar-strawczynski-cross-pollination-holocaust-memory/.