An Analysis and Refutation of Factitious
“Evidence,” Deceptions and Flawed Argumentation of the “Holocaust
Controversies” Bloggers
by Carlo Mattogno, Thomas Kues and Jürgen Graf
Published: 2013-10-23
Ever since the authors of the
present study started publishing, together or separately, thorough studies
about the most prominent German camps of the WWII era which are generally
referred to as extermination camps, orthodox historians have made it a point to
intentionally ignore these studies which they seem unable to refute. This eerie
silence ended only in late 2011 when several members of the exterminationist Holocaust
Controversies blog published a 570 page-long online study titled Belzec,
Sobibor, Treblinka: Holocaust Denial and Operation Reinhard. With it they
claim to refute three of our authors’ monographs on the camps Belzec, Sobibor
and Treblinka (see vols. 9, 19 and 8 of the Holocaust Handbooks series).
This lengthy orthodox critique
forced our three authors to go back to the sources. After a year of archival
and library research, the rebuttal of their detractors’ critique was finally
complete, and a few months later Mattogno’s major contributions to it were
translated into English. The opus seemed ready for publication. What followed
next, though, was an arduous, 6-months-lasting process of thorough
fact-checking and archival verification by peer reviewers as well as massive
lingual improvements by numerous editors. The results are out in the open now:
a work comprising more than 1,500 pages.
This work has occupied the
most knowledgeable revisionists for a year and more. It has led to the
postponement of numerous other projects (as can easily be gleaned from this
website as well). Today’s leading revisionists consider this their ultimate
response and final word on the subject. From now on they have promised to focus
on more productive research and publications.
As to the contents of this
book, the casual reader may be warned: This work cannot be read like a novel.
It is a point-by-point response to the above-mentioned Holocaust
Controversies bloggers’ PDF file (accessible on their website) and can be
understood only in that context. It also requires that the reader be familiar
with the authors’ three monographs on the Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka camps,
all of which can be accessed and downloaded on this website.
It goes without saying that it
is neither easy nor profitable to publish such a huge two-volume opus which
will find only a very small audience. In order to make the text a little more
readable and to reduce the volume of the printed version slightly, it does
include only the English translations of any foreign language sources quoted.
The full foreign language text can be found in the extended PDF version. Since
this PDF file is accessible to everyone and can thus be searched, we have
refrained from creating a cost-prohibitive index.
In summarizing the book’s
conclusions, Jürgen Graf writes in his Epilogue:
"Holocaust Controversies
had all the time they needed to write their “refutation.” They were assisted by
a host of Holocaust historians they diligently enumerate in their introduction.
It did not help them a bit. […] Since the exterminationist position with
regards to these two topics [gas chambers and eyewitnesses] is hopeless from
the beginning, Myers had myriads of opportunities to make a fool of himself,
and he missed not a single one of them. […]
However, the most preposterous
chapters of the pamphlet are undoubtedly the two last ones, written by […]
Roberto Muehlenkamp, who unsuccessfully tried to prove that during World War II
the eternal laws of nature had to pause so that the evil Nazis could carry out
their massacre in chemical slaughterhouses and get rid of the bodies without
significant use of fuel. [Muehlenkamp] knew exactly that Mattogno, who has an
encyclopedic knowledge of all problems related to cremation, would react to his
challenge and make mincemeat of his chapters, to use Romanov’s poetic formulation
for the last time. Is Muehlenkamp perhaps a masochist? Does he relish the role
of the circus clown who is pelted with eggs to the roaring laughter of the
audience? Now he has egg all over his face. I do not feel a bit sorry for him
because he asked for it."
Note
This book exists in two
versions: a “short” printed version which does not include most of the foreign
language quotes, and an extended PDF version which includes all foreign
language quotes. The print version’s PDF files can be downloaded with the usual
links below. The extended PDF version of 1554 pp. is available here (37.7 MB).
2nd, slightly corrected edition, Set of 2 tomes
with a total of 1396 pages.
Tome 1: 712 pp. ISBN13: 9781591480877 (ISBN10: 1591480876)
Tome 2: 684 pp. ISBN13: 9781591480884 (ISBN10: 1591480884)
Format: pb, 6"×9", bibliography.
Published by Castle Hill Publishers (Uckfield, UK) in Apr. 2015.
For prices please see retail outlets.
Tome 1: 712 pp. ISBN13: 9781591480877 (ISBN10: 1591480876)
Tome 2: 684 pp. ISBN13: 9781591480884 (ISBN10: 1591480884)
Format: pb, 6"×9", bibliography.
Published by Castle Hill Publishers (Uckfield, UK) in Apr. 2015.
For prices please see retail outlets.
Purchase Options
Note: Books published by Castle Hill Publishers
should be available anywhere books are sold – except for those companies
boycotting us, like Amazon and Barnes & Noble. Search other online stores
using the book-price search-engine links provided below, or when searching
other stores use the ISBN number provided above. Also ask your local book store
to order it for you. They should be able to get it for you.
No comments:
Post a Comment